EDHEC-Risk Climate Newsletter - July 2024 Issue
Delivering Research Insights Double Materiality to the Financial Community

Forward to a colleague

Subscribe to our Newsletter

EDHEC-Risk Climate Newsletter - July 2024 Issue

EDHEC-Risk Climate - Quarterly Newsletter - Academic Roots and Practitioner Reach

Editorial

Edito - Finance of Transition, Transition of Finance (Frederic Ducoulombier)

Finance of Transition, Transition of Finance

Transitioning to low emissions and resilient economies “to secure a liveable and sustainable future for all” requires prompt action and considerable investment in climate change mitigation and adaptation. While substantial, the required investments are within the realm of global financial capabilities: their total amount pales relative to world GDP, government expenditures, and naturally, the accumulated wealth or the stock of financial assets. However, private investments and public funds directed towards mitigation and adaptation projects need to increase many times over current levels. The Paris Agreement, now close to a decade old, aims to catalyse this shift, but the systemic alignment of financial resources―whether public or private, domestic or international―with the goals of climate change mitigation and adaptation is still far off.

Table of Contents

1. Feature | 2. Interview | 3. Industry Analysis | 4. EDHEC-Risk Climate Publications | 5. EDHEC Research Beyond EDHEC-Risk Climate | 6. Videos & Podcasts | 7. Education | 8. News | 9. Forthcoming Events | 10. Press Review | 11. Recruitment

Feature

Sizing Up the Climate Threat to Global Equity Values – A Novel Approach

EDHEC-Risk Climate Impact Institute's Scientific Director, Riccardo Rebonato, presents key findings from new research titled "How Does Climate Risk Affect Global Equity Valuations? A Novel Approach," supported by Scientific Beta. This work addresses limitations in current climate-aware valuation approaches and offers new insights into the impact of climate risk on asset valuations. The research introduces a novel framework that integrates asset pricing techniques with Integrated Assessment Models. It features a fully probabilistic treatment of economic and climate uncertainties, state-dependent discounting, and a consistent analysis of transition costs and physical damages. Key findings reveal that equity valuations are significantly affected by the aggressiveness of emission abatement policies, the presence of climate tipping points, and central banks' ability to lower rates during economic distress. The study shows potential valuation impacts ranging from less than 10% with robust abatement actions to over 50% in scenarios with minimal action and tipping points. This pioneering research highlights the critical importance of aggressive emission abatement policies to mitigate financial impacts, providing valuable insights for policymakers, investors, and financial institutions integrating climate risks into their valuation models.

Interview

Interview - Tech-Driven Resilience: Evaluating ESG Impacts and Risks in Infrastructure Investments

Tech-Driven Resilience: Evaluating ESG Impacts and Risks in Infrastructure Investments

In this interview, Rob Arnold, Sustainability Research Director at EDHEC-Risk Climate Impact Institute, discusses the creation of a new body of knowledge on decarbonization and climate resilience strategies in infrastructure sectors. He explains the necessity and beneficiaries of this knowledge, the project's structure, and how it addresses climate risks. Rob also talks about his collaboration with EDHEC Infra & Private Assets Research Institute on sustainable infrastructure taxonomies, the relevance to non-financial companies and investors, and the challenges in collecting climate risk data. Drawing on his experience as a senior advisor to the UK Government, he shares insights on supporting global transition and resilience efforts.

Industry Analysis

Internal Carbon Pricing: Impact or Greenwashing?

Companies are increasingly called to collaborate in the fight against climate change in a context of rising public awareness for the need to accelerate decarbonisation and of an emerging global climate governance. New tools for climate mitigation are emerging to assist with the delivery of corporate greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions objectives, with internal carbon pricing (ICP) becoming a widespread practice globally. ICP is a voluntary method for companies to internalise the social cost of their GHG emissions, even when all or part of their operations are out of the scope of external carbon regulations. Understanding internal carbon pricing is thus becoming essential to corporates and investors alike. The authors study the relationship between internal carbon price reporting and carbon footprint to assess the credibility of corporates' disclosures. Specifically, they study whether ICP adoption helps companies deliver on carbon footprint reduction or whether it is just a greenwashing exercise.

Assessing the RCP / SSP Framework for Financial Decision Making

The SSP/RCP framework is a powerful construct which has been central to how policymakers develop mitigation strategies and which has been embraced by the financial community. However, the authors believe that the scenarios which are developed using a series of models should be subject to scrutiny using well established model risk management approaches. Specifically, the framework is deliberately built as a set of scenarios with no associated probabilities, which is challenging for investors to use meaningfully with no view as to likelihood, dispersion and risks around the single paths. They highlight areas where the design might lead to an underestimation of the risk, potentially giving rise to a false sense of security on the impacts of climate change and how transition might unfold.

Dealing with Climate Change: Asset Pricing Implications of Monetary and Fiscal Choices

To fully decarbonize the economy by mid-century, abatement initiatives are required for which unsubsidized private intervention is less likely to provide financing than has been the case so far. Public involvement will have to take the form of higher taxation or higher debt. In the present condition of unprecedentedly high public debt, and of reluctance to accept higher taxation, this creates a trilemma between public debt, level of taxation, and level of abatement. If the second phase of the green transition is mainly financed by debt, the global debt burden could rise by as much as 40%, putting pressure on interest rates. This would have direct repercussions on the price of government bonds, and an indirect effect on equity valuation via the discounting channel.

EDHEC-Risk Climate – Practitioner Publications

How Does Climate Risk Affect Global Equity Valuations? A Novel Approach

How Does Climate Risk Affect Global Equity Valuations? A Novel Approach

The study, conducted within the research chair established by EDHEC Business School and Scientific Beta, introduces an innovative approach to understanding the impact of climate change and climate change policies on global equity valuations. Sensitivity analyses reveal that the severity of the impact on equity markets depends on the pace of abatement, on the precise location of tipping points, and on the continued ability by Central Banks to counter periods of economic distress by lowering rates. The study finds that even in the absence of tipping points, failure to take abatement action can reduce global equity valuation by over 40%.

EDHEC Research Insights Supplement with IPE

EDHEC Research Insights Supplement with IPE

The inaugural EDHEC-Risk Climate Impact Institute issue of the EDHEC Research Insights supplement to Investment & Pensions Europe analyses climate scenarios, scrutinizes the IPCC RCP/SSP framework, examines the next decarbonization phase, discusses the lack of correlation between internal carbon price disclosure and carbon intensity reduction, explores the materiality of value chain emissions, and investigates how extreme weather events influence mutual fund managers’ investment decisions.

Scope for Divergence

Scope for Divergence

This policy report offers comprehensive insights into accounting for greenhouse gas emissions throughout companies’ value chains, and the challenges this process poses to companies and investors. Regulators are caught up in the contentious debate between investors and environmental NGOs who favour disclosure and business organisations and politicians representing fossil fuel interests who oppose it. The report explains how fiduciaries can ensure that consideration of value chain emissions issues is fit for purpose and how standard setters can avoid abetting greenwashing. It concludes with recommendations to companies, investors, and policymakers to enhance the quality, relevance, and cost-efficiency of disclosures.

EDHEC-Risk Climate – Working Papers

Decarbonization and the Pace of Economic Growth

Decarbonization and the Pace of Economic Growth

The authors use an adaptation of a popular Integrated Assessment Model, according to which the carbon intensity, the rate of growth of the population and the cost of abatement technologies all strongly fall with GDP per capita to explore whether this implies that the end-of-century temperature will vary with states of high or low economic output. They find that, despite what they call the 'technological optimism' of the model, high (low) temperature outcomes are strongly associated with high (low) states of GDP or GDP per person. They also find that a robust abatement policy can effectively reduce temperature increases, even along paths of high GDP per person, strengthening the case for aggressive abatement policy.

The Link Between Physical and Transition Risk

The Link Between Physical and Transition Risk

The authors argue that what is usually referred to as climate 'transition risk' can be more usefully decomposed in an expectation part and a variability around this central value. They show the strong inverse relationship between the expectation component of transition costs and the expectation of physical damages, as well as a method of how to estimate this relationship. Results indicate that the uncertainty in transition costs decreases as the abatement policy becomes more aggressive (and physical damage decreases) but remains large as a fraction of the expectation component.

EDHEC Research Beyond EDHEC-Risk Climate

Scientific Portfolio - Dark Green Equity Funds Could go 'Full Green' With Very Limited Impact on Their Risk Profile

Scientific Portfolio: “Dark Green” Equity Funds Could go “Full Green” With Very Limited Impact on Their Risk Profile

Sustainable investment funds have blown up in size in the last decade. However, many funds that claim to be sustainable still contain stocks of companies involved in greenhouse gas-intensive industries. In this article, Scientific Portfolio (an EDHEC Venture) researchers present their latest study in which they analyse the impact of the exclusion of these controversial stocks on the performance and risk profile of these funds.

Scientific Portfolio - Decomposition of Greenhouse Gas Emissions Associated With an Equity Portfolio

Scientific Portfolio: Decomposition of Greenhouse Gas Emissions Associated With an Equity Portfolio

In this paper, the authors introduce a decomposition method that enables the disentanglement of five factors that influence the emissions of a portfolio. The method can be applied to different climate impact metrics such as emissions intensity, footprint, or absolute emissions. The analysis can be historical or cross-sectional and can help decision makers achieve reduction targets compatible with climate objectives. It can also be used to uncover greenwashing in portfolio decarbonisation.

Scientific Portfolio/Institut Louis Bachelier: Implied Temperature Rise of equity portfolios: a sensitivity analysis framework

Scientific Portfolio/Institut Louis Bachelier: Implied Temperature Rise of equity portfolios: a sensitivity analysis framework

This report is part of the Consolidated Alignment Performance Analytics research project, developed and led by the Institut Louis Bachelier Labs in partnership with Scientific Portfolio (an EDHEC venture), and financed by the French environmental agency ADEME. The results build on the findings presented in the report “The Alignment Cookbook 2 - A technical panorama of the alignment methodologies and metrics used by and applied to the financial sector, with a view to inform consolidated alignment assessments”. This report introduces a framework for conducting sensitivity analyses of design choices in calculating a company's or financial portfolio's implied temperature rise (ITR), highlighting the impact of different carbon budget allocations on decarbonization benchmarks.

EDHEC Infra & Private Assets: Physical climate risk survey: those in the infrastructure investment industry are concerned and lack data

EDHEC Infra & Private Assets: Physical Climate Risk Survey: Those in the Infrastructure Investment Industry are Concerned and Lack Data

The survey revealed significant apprehensions and knowledge gaps among respondents. Concerned investors emphasised the urgent need for better data and information regarding physical climate risks in infrastructure investments. Importantly, the survey confirms that despite the recognised importance of physical climate risk, investors and managers lack sufficient tools and knowledge to assess its impact on their portfolios effectively.

EDHEC Infra & Private Assets: Infrastructure Decarbonisation and Resilience Strategies

EDHEC Infra & Private Assets: Using Taxonomies to Qualify the Sustainability

This paper examines the role that green taxonomies play in defining and identifying sustainable infrastructure investments. The urgency of climate change and the global effort to transition to low-carbon economies has seen the development of multiple frameworks, taxonomies, and standards. This report analysed the challenges of using and interpreting an activity-based taxonomy to categorise infrastructure assets as sustainable (or not) and proposes key improvements that can support the applicability of such taxonomies to the infrastructure asset class.

Climate risk and financial stability - evidence from syndicated lending

Climate risk and financial stability: evidence from syndicated lending

The authors study the impact of unexpected climate shocks on banks' individual and systemic risks. Employing climate risk measures developed using the Billion-Dollar Weather and Climate Disasters data from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) and Dealscan syndicated lending data, they find that climate risk exposure acquired through cross-state lending increases banks' individual and systemic risks. They also find that bank profitability helps offset some of the adverse effects of climate risk. Banks reduce lending and increase loan loss reserves after the experience of an unexpected climate shock.

Videos & Podcasts

EDHEC-Risk Climate Research Presentations

Riccardo Rebonato and Dherminder Kainth - How to Enhance Climate Scenarios for Investors - EDHEC Risk Climate Webinar

Riccardo Rebonato & Dherminder Kainth: "How to Enhance Climate Scenarios for Investors", EDHEC Risk Climate Webinar

Rob Arnold - Reporting Standards to Address Resilience for Investors - OECD Forum

Rob Arnold: "Reporting Standards to Address Resilience for Investors", OECD Forum

Scientific Portfolio, an EDHEC Venture

Vincent Bouchet - The Alignment Cookbook 2 - the Institut Louis Bachelier

Vincent Bouchet: "The Alignment Cookbook 2", the Institut Louis Bachelier

Scientific Portfolio - Equity Portfolio Technology for Institutional Asset Owners

Scientific Portfolio: Equity Portfolio Technology for Institutional Asset Owners

EDHEC Speaker series "The Future of Finance"

Bob Litterman - Kapos Capital - Carbon Pricing - Can Financial Engineering Save the Planet

Bob Litterman (Kapos Capital): "Carbon Pricing: Can Financial Engineering Save the Planet?"

Jules H. van Binsbergen (Wharton University of Pennsylvania)- 'The Impact of Impact Investing'

Jules H. van Binsbergen (Wharton University of Pennsylvania): "The Impact of Impact Investing"

Education

	 Financial Times 2024 World Ranking of master’s in finance

Financial Times 2024 World Ranking of Masters in Finance: EDHEC Moves up 3 Places to 6th in the World

EDHEC has confirmed its leading position in international finance education. This remarkable achievement reaffirms EDHEC's commitment to providing top-tier finance education and aligns perfectly with its "Generations 2050" strategic plan, which emphasizes the importance of sustainable finance.

EDHEC's open executive programmes ranked among the Top 5 worldwide by the Financial Times

EDHEC's Open Executive Programmes Ranked Among the Top 5 Worldwide by the Financial Times

EDHEC’s executive programmes continue to move up in the Financial Times business school rankings. The new FT ranking highlights the loyalty of companies working with EDHEC to develop their top managers and executives, as well as participant satisfaction. EDHEC is committed to providing education with real-world impact, equipping executives with the skills and expertise needed to navigate the challenges of climate change and technology, ensuring their organizations can achieve financial resilience and growth.

News

Top 10 Most Read Articles from EDHEC-Risk Climate in the First Half of 2024

Top 10 Most Read Articles from EDHEC-Risk Climate in the First Half of 2024

As we move into the Summer, a period of reflection and anticipation, EDHEC-Risk Climate Impact Institute takes a moment to look back at the most-read articles in the past six months. These articles cover a diverse range of topics at the heart of our expertise (climate change, climate risks, climate scenarios analysis, greenwashing regulation, double materiality, sustainability reporting, Scope 3 emissions, and carbon pricing).

'Generations 2050' EDHEC Launches its New Strategic Plan 2024-2028

"Generations 2050": EDHEC Launches its New Strategic Plan 2024-2028

EDHEC Business School has unveiled its new strategic plan, "Generations 2050," focusing on addressing global challenges and fostering a sustainable future. A key highlight of this ambitious plan is the establishment of a dedicated "Climate Finance School," led by the EDHEC-Risk Climate Impact Institute. This initiative aims to consolidate expertise, disseminate best practices in climate finance, and prepare students and stakeholders to tackle climate finance challenges effectively.

ESG Data Abundance and Evolving Investor Needs

ESG Data Abundance and Evolving Investor Needs: Insights from Frédéric Ducoulombier at RI Europe Conference

Frédéric Ducoulombier, Director of EDHEC-Risk Climate Impact Institute contributed to a panel discussion titled "ESG data: meeting the evolving needs of responsible investors” at Responsible Investor’s annual European conference. This event was held in front of 600+ leading institutional investors to discuss the fast-changing sustainability regulations, the need to take decarbonization to the next stage, and the tools to support that transition even in uncertain political times.

EDHEC-Vox (Newsletter 7) Climate Change: Changing Finance is Out

EDHEC-Vox (Newsletter #7) Climate Change: Changing Finance is Out

Although the financial players have begun to change in response to the urgent need to tackle climate change, they are far from doing so quickly enough and to the right extent. But how can they be supported and equipped? This month, in the new issue of the #EDHECVox newsletter, our professors and researchers present their thoughts and concrete proposals on this subject.

Rob Arnold invited to discuss the imperative of enhancing infrastructure resilience at OECD's Forum

Rob Arnold Invited to Discuss the Imperative of Enhancing Infrastructure Resilience at OECD's Forum

Rob Arnold took part in a panel discussion on "Reporting standards to address resilience for investors” at the OECD Infrastructure Forum: Infrastructure for Resilience in Paris. Expert panelists discussed the integration of project-level certification with company-level reporting standards, focusing on enhancing sustainability and resilience in infrastructure investments.

A great success for the webinar - How to Enhance Climate Scenarios for Investors

A Great Success for the Webinar 'How to Enhance Climate Scenarios for Investors'

Existing climate scenarios, inspired by the IPCC framework, provide invaluable insights but were not designed for financial uses. During the webinar, attended by over 700 professionals, R. Rebonato and D. Kainth presented findings from their latest foundational white paper titled “Climate Scenario Analysis and Stress Testing for Investors: A Probabilistic Approach”, exploring approaches to enrich the existing framework with probabilistic information.

Forthcoming Events

30 September 2024

Reuter Events: Sustainability Europe 2024

Frédéric Ducoulombier will participate in two panel discussions at the Sustainable Investment Stage during Sustainability Europe 2024. Drawing from his experience in sustainable finance regulation, he will discuss the evolving regulatory landscapes, focusing on the SFDR's future and the importance of consistent regulatory interpretations. He will provide insights on the latest regulatory developments and their implications for sustainable investment strategies.


27 November 2024

Scientific Beta Days Europe 2024

Riccardo Rebonato will discuss the impact of climate change on global equity valuation. Drawing from new research by EDHEC-Risk Climate Impact Institute, supported by Scientific Beta, he will discuss the effects of climate tipping points, the importance of state-dependent discounting, and the influence of risk premia on equity valuations under different climate scenarios.


Press Review

EDHEC-Risk Climate has been cited widely in the business and industry press. A selection of articles may be found below.

Death by a thousand cuts - why climate risk isn’t priced in, Net Zero Investor

“Death by a thousand cuts” - why climate risk isn’t priced in, Net Zero Investor (03/05/2024)

Guest Viewpoint - The SEC Should Not Diverge on Scope 3 - IPE

Guest Viewpoint: The SEC Should Not Diverge on Scope 3”, IPE (01/03/2024)

Recruitment